Title: Saving Shiloh Author: Phyllis Reynolds Naylor Average number of words per page: between 50 and 100 STORY: 35 readers have rated this story. Average story rating: 8.05/10.0 ILLUSTRATIONS: 35 readers have rated the illustrations. Average illustration rating: 6.53/10.0

Purchase this book from Amazon View larger image Review the book cover art

Book review by: Jennifer age: 14 Review submitted on 04/15/2002 at 11:02:04 list all 35 reviews for this book

Story Rating 8.0 out of a possible 10.0

Jennifer writes the following about Saving Shiloh :

"Saving Shiloh" is a thrilling conclusion of the Shiloh trilogy. The setting in this book is in West Virgina where the main character, Marty,lives. In the previous books Marty found out that Judd travers was abusing his dog Shiloh. So Marty made a deal with Judd and after many months of hard work and cleaning Marty got to keep Shiloh. In this book Judd is trying to change, but no one will take him sercioulsy. After a while when people start to think that judd is a reasonable guy a murder occurs! Everyone believes Judd did it. What do you think? At the end of the book Judd gets his chance to prove himself a hero, but does he act on the scene or does he just walk away? The theme of this story is not to judge people before you really know them. I give this book a 8 out of 10. I only give it an 8 because it didn't include Shiloh very much. Over all this book was exciting, and it made you want to never put it down. I recomend reading it.

recommend this review to a friend Christian book reviews