The Curriculum Archive is a central repository for free lessons and classroom projects. You can earn extra income while contributing your ideas to this collective resource. Read this information to find out about payment schedules.
Fudge
truffles
caramels
Before teaching this lesson, you may want to view the prerequisite lesson : "Popular Mechanics" by Raymond Carver

He Said, She Said
Author: Betty Dobry
email: en2english@netscape.net
Grade Levels:
undergraduate
Subjects:
drama
reading
writing
Discuss this lesson:
read lesson feedback
submit feedback
recommend this lesson to a friend or colleage

Quality rating:
2 users have rated this lesson quality.
Average quality rating: 9.25 / 10.0
Creativity rating:
2 users have rated the creativity.
Average creativity rating: 9.5 / 10.0

Themes or Keywords : Marital Disputes/Conflicts, Divorce/Separation, Selfish Motivations

Objectives :

1. To teach students that real life sometimes happens in literature.

2. To teach students to listen and critically think about the major conflicts and themes in short stories.

Materials :

  • Copies of the short story "Popular Mechanics"
  • Paper
  • Two different colors of high lighter markers

Introductory Questions :

  • What does the title mean and what might it suggest before reading it?
  • Is anyone at fault in a domestic dispute?

Introductory Activity :

Have students read the short story individually. After giving them approximately 5 to 10 minutes to read it, ask them to discuss the sequence of events that take place in the story. Discuss the meaning of theme, motive, and conflict.

Body :

Divide the class into small groups (3 to 4 in each group). Give the small groups approximately 20 minutes to complete this portion of the assignment. Have each group highlight the dialogue in two different colors to separate what the husband says and what the wife says. Have the students circle the rest of the text to use as a narrator.

Conclusion Activity :

Either have three students to volunteer to read the separated version of the story or choose three students to read the individual parts to the class. Discuss how it sounds being read aloud by three of their fellow classmates compared to being read individually. Discuss with the class the difference in opinion between the motives of the husband and the wife and the impact it has on them being read aloud. Also ask the students to explain the theme(s), motives, and conflicts between this married couple.

Vocabulary Words :

  • theme
  • motive
  • conflict

Evaluation Activity :

Using this piece of literature have the students write a paragraph response (eight to ten sentences) to why and what caused this domestic situation to unfold as it did. Allow students another 15 minutes to write their responses.


How well does this lesson fulfill it's objectives? Click here to rate the quality of this lesson.


Go To CurriculumArchive Home Page SEARCH Curriculum Archive ADD a lesson BROWSE lessons DISCUSS
copyright statement

contact the webmaster